Are Silicone Scar Sheets Really Effective? My Honest Results

Before and After: What You Can Expect

Scars tell stories—but some stories are not ones we want permanently visible on our skin. Nine months ago, I had a forearm injury that required surgical repair. The procedure went smoothly, the wound closed properly, and everything seemed on track. But as the months passed, I noticed something: the scar didn’t fade. Instead, it became thicker, raised, and darker than I expected. At first, I thought it was just normal healing. Eventually, I realized the scar was becoming more obvious instead of improving.

Like many Filipinos, my first solution was Cébo de Macho—the classic go-to product for newly healed wounds. I applied it regularly as soon as the wound closed, hoping it would lighten or flatten the scar. It did help moisturize the skin, but it didn’t change the thickness or texture. The scar remained raised and slightly darker. That was the moment I decided to research deeper.

I’ve never really cared about my older scars—most of them are reminders of how much I enjoyed playing outside as a kid. For years, I believed a scar is just a scar. I had no idea about raised or thick scars, and even the word “keloid” was something I often heard but never understood because I wasn’t interested.

That changed when I remembered a 7-year-old scar on my knee caused by a piece of metal sticking out from a tricycle. It was a small scratch, but the scar formed a dark, raised line that never went away.

So when my surgical wound healed, I immediately applied traditional Cébo de Macho to prevent the scar from darkening. I never expected it to become raised and darker over time. That’s when I realized that while Cébo de Macho helps moisturize the skin, it isn’t effective for scar management—especially raised scars.

This experience awakened my interest in scar-care products. The first recommendation I received was from my sister, who sent me a photo of a silicone scar sheet. I was skeptical because it wasn’t a cream or oil—it literally looked like tape. But eventually, I decided to give it a chance. Before trying it, I researched everything I could find online, including medical explanations and user reviews. Because there was a huge gap between “before and after” results in what I found online, I decided to document my own journey. I took photos of my progress every day to see if silicone scar sheets actually work—and to help others who might also be searching for answers.

This documentation will run for about 3 months or until I see a significant difference. For now, I will share my weekly progress on this blog. For those looking for proof, I hope the final results of this journey will help you decide whether silicone scar sheets are the right option for you compared to other treatments available on the market. Stay updated for my journey and progress. Here are the weekly before-and-after photos so far:

Week 1: Before & After (11-09-25)

Week 2: Before & After (11-18-25)

Week 3: Before & After (11-26-25)

‹

›

Understanding Raised Scars

I know many of you might still feel skeptical, but based on my research, there is real science behind silicone scar sheet—and it is still considered the gold standard for non-invasive scar management i learn that there are two types of raised scars:

1. Hypertrophic Scars

• Raised but stay within the boundary of the original wound
• Firm, thick, and often red or dark
• Common after surgery, burns, or injuries
• May improve slowly over time
• Respond very well to silicone scar sheets

2. Keloid Scars

• Grow beyond the edge of the wound
• Smooth, shiny, or rubbery
• Sometimes itchy or painful
• Caused by excessive collagen production
• More difficult to treat and often require multiple therapies

After comparing my scar with medical references, it became clear that mine was hypertrophic. It was raised, but it never extended beyond the surgical line. And maybe you also wondering same as mine as how this "tape like" can become effective in scar managment? 

The Science Behind Silicone Scar Sheets 

Here is what i learn; "Raised scars—both hypertrophic and keloid—are caused by excess collagen produced during healing. When the body senses injury, it rushes to repair the damage. But sometimes, the collagen response becomes too aggressive, creating a raised scar."

Imagine your scar is like dry, cracked soil. When soil becomes dry, it hardens, becomes uneven, and cracks. But when you cover it and keep it moist, the ground slowly softens and levels out. That’s exactly what silicone does to a scar.

Here’s what I personally observed:

1. It keeps the scar hydrated so it doesn’t harden.
The silicone sheet acts like a light cover that locks in moisture. Before, my scar felt dry and stiff—like it wanted to puff up. With silicone, it stayed soft, and the skin stopped producing excess collagen. It’s like the skin finally realized it didn’t need to “overreact.”

2. The gentle pressure works like placing a book on wrinkled paper.
If you press a book on wrinkled paper for a long time, the paper slowly flattens. Silicone works the same way. The pressure is mild but consistent, and over time, the scar becomes flatter and less thick.

3. The color and texture improved gradually.
With consistent use, the scar became smoother, less raised, and its redness faded. It also became less itchy and looked more like the surrounding skin. It wasn’t an overnight change, but the progress was noticeable.

4. It’s safe and backed by science—not just marketing.
Unlike oils or whitening creams that only work on the surface, silicone targets the structure of the scar. This is why doctors recommend it for burn scars and surgical wounds.

Overall, using silicone felt like giving my scar the right environment to calm down, soften, and slowly blend in. If I had to compare it, I’d say:

It’s like putting a protective greenhouse cover over your scar—keeping the conditions perfect so it can heal properly without growing wild.

Which Brand I Used

There are a lot of silicone scar sheets out there, and you can easily grab them online on Shopee, Lazada, or even TikTok. I first tried West&Month’s Silicone Scar Sheet (SSS) since it was super affordable. Also, Silicon Scar Sheet Ilaimei becuase it matched my skin tone better and stuck more securely.

The great thing is, you can reuse them! Just wash gently with mild soap, let it air dry, and you’re good to go. As long as it still sticks well, you can keep using it multiple times. 

For international buyers outside the Philippines, you can order online via eBay, Amazon, or directly from the Ilaimei website. I’m pretty sure it’s also available in your country. This product is imported from the UK, so it’s likely listed on online platforms where you live.